Tim Goodman / Bastard Machine

Tim Goodman / Bastard Machine

Share this post

Tim Goodman / Bastard Machine
Tim Goodman / Bastard Machine
"Baby Reindeer."

"Baby Reindeer."

The Netflix series gets the Two Episode Test and becomes the shortest TET yet!

Tim Goodman's avatar
Tim Goodman
Apr 29, 2024
∙ Paid
23

Share this post

Tim Goodman / Bastard Machine
Tim Goodman / Bastard Machine
"Baby Reindeer."
27
1
Share

You probably fall into three categories when it comes to “Baby Reindeer,” the new, almost indescribable series on Netflix.

  1. Never heard of it and never seen it.

  2. Everybody is either telling you to watch it or not watch it, which has become like a ceaseless drumming and says more about them, depending on what they are telling you to do, than about the show.

  3. You already watched it.

(If No. 3 is true, I would hedge a guess that you either burned right through it immediately or stopped cold pretty early on.)

For transparency sake I will tell you what most of you already know — that I read almost nothing about a show before I see it on purpose and there’s less than a handful of critics I even bother with when the time comes to read a review and usually that time is after I’ve already watched.

In the case of “Baby Reindeer” not that long ago, a friend told me about it via text.

I’d never heard of it.

Someone had told him about it. But also: “It’s all over the Netflix site.” Me: “Everybody has a different algorithm and I’ve never even seen the name, but I’ll check it out sometime.”

Response: “No, I really think it’s everywhere on Netflix?”

And: “You gotta see this.”

I went and looked at my Netflix landing page, a mash-up of choices that reminded me of the American Music Club song “Johnny Mathis’ Feet,” where singer-songwriter Mark Eitzel asks Johnny Mathis how to live.

It’s one of my favorite AMC songs ever, filled with magisterial bleakness and astonishingly great writing, where in one stanza Eitzel says:

“Johnny looked at/My old collection of punk rock posters/Anonymous scenes of disaffection, chaos and torture.”

So, yeah, that’s my Netflix landing page.

But, huh, there it was — “Baby Reindeer.”

Even with that brilliant title I guess it just washed across my eyes like some cosmic speck in the infinite stardust of social media click-bait, dopamine hits and egregiously TMI trailers on every streaming platform I subscribe to…and I just missed it?

In the song, the fictional Johnny Mathis does give Eitzel tons of life advice, and I will share this line before diving into the shortest Two Episode Test I can recall:

Johnny looked at my songs and he said
“Well at first guess, never in my life
Have I ever seen such a mess
Why do you say everything as if you were a thief?
Like what you've stolen has no value
Like what you preach is far from belief?”

And with a wave of his red, white and blue hand
Across the glittering Hollywood scene,

He said
“You gotta learn how to disappear in the silk and amphetamine
In the silk and amphetamine.”

Hello free friends: Being a paid subscriber is only $6 a month or, a better value, $50 a year. There’s a very deep archive with useful and interesting content to guide your viewing choices, the NEW Bastard Machine Podcast, a vibrant community of smart commenters and a number of ongoing, creative features you won't find anywhere else.

Creator, writer, star and victim, Richard Gadd stars in the British limited series, “Baby Reindeer” on Netflix.

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to Tim Goodman / Bastard Machine to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Tim Goodman
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share